Crafting Your Memoir's Backbone: Chronology vs. Theme

05/08/2023

Not all stories are told from start to finish. Sometimes, the heart of the tale lies in its structure. For as long as stories have been shared, the battle between chronology and theme has raged on, each offering a distinct pathway through the narrative landscape. 

While a chronological approach provides a linear, time-bound journey, allowing readers to follow the protagonist's evolution step by step, thematic storytelling delves deep into core ideas, interweaving moments from different times to paint a holistic portrait of the narrative's essence. With memoirs, this choice is paramount. It can determine not just how events are relayed, but how readers connect, empathize, and extract meaning from the author's life experiences. 

Choosing between chronology and theme is  a reflection of how one wishes their story to resonate and linger in the reader's mind.

Choosing between chronology and theme is more than a structural decision; it's a reflection of how one wishes their story to resonate and linger in the reader's mind. As memoirists, we must ask ourselves: Do we want to transport readers through the passages of time, allowing them to witness our growth and changes? Or would we prefer to navigate them through a series of pivotal themes and moments, irrespective of when they occurred, emphasizing lessons and insights? The decision, while seemingly technical, profoundly shapes the heart and soul of one's memoir, guiding the reader's journey and determining how they perceive and connect with the story's essence.

Examples of Varied Structured Memoirs


Chronological: The Glass Castle by Jeannette Walls

In The Glass Castle, Jeannette Walls crafts a riveting narrative that unfolds chronologically, tracing her life from a challenging childhood to an eventual escape to New York. Walls recounts her experiences growing up in severe poverty with dysfunctional parents, moving from one dilapidated place to another. By adopting a linear structure, she effectively takes readers on a journey through the ups and downs, allowing them to witness the evolution of her family dynamics, her own personal growth, and the series of events that led her to break free from her tumultuous past. This chronological approach not only simplifies the complex tapestry of her life but also emphasizes the stark contrast between her early hardships and later successes, providing a powerful testament to resilience and determination.

Thematic: In Eat, Pray, Love by Elizabeth Gilbert

In Eat, Pray, Love, Elizabeth Gilbert embarks on a soul-searching journey, but rather than simply narrating her year abroad in a chronological manner, she divides her tale into three distinct thematic segments: Pleasure (in Italy), Devotion (in India), and Balance (in Indonesia). This thematic division allows Gilbert to delve deeply into each transformative phase of her journey, presenting not just a series of events but a progression of emotions, realizations, and personal growth. By structuring her memoir around these central themes, she provides readers with a more profound understanding of her internal struggles and revelations, ensuring that each segment resonates with its intended emotion and lesson. This thematic approach offers a refreshing departure from traditional linear storytelling, demonstrating the power of structure in shaping a memoir's impact.

Mixed Structure: Wild by Cheryl Strayed

Mixed Structure: Wild stands as a masterclass in blended memoir structure. While Cheryl Strayed primarily recounts her grueling journey along the Pacific Crest Trail in a chronological order, she frequently veers into thematic flashbacks, diving into moments from her past that informed her decision to embark on the trip. These flashbacks, often laden with emotional intensity, are seamlessly woven into the main narrative, providing readers with context and depth about Strayed's internal motivations and challenges. This mixed structure not only showcases the events of her hike but emphasizes the emotional growth and healing that occurred both before and during her journey. Through this intricate weaving of past and present, Wild offers a layered exploration of personal redemption and resilience.

Selecting the Ideal Narrative Structure


The Appeal of Chronology:‚Äč

A chronological approach to storytelling, often favored for its clarity and directness, lays out events in the order they transpired, offering readers an intuitive roadmap of the narrative. This linear progression naturally forms an arc, making it easier for readers to trace and understand the growth or transformation of the protagonist. By moving from point A to point B in a predictable sequence, a chronological structure allows for the meticulous building of character dynamics, challenges faced, and lessons learned. For many memoirs, this structure resonates strongly as it mirrors the way we typically recall our life events, and it can be especially poignant when highlighting a transformative journey over time.

The Depth of Theme

Embracing a thematic structure in memoirs opens doors to profound introspection and exploration. Rather than following a linear progression, the narrative delves into specific emotions, events, or insights, often diving deep into each one. This approach allows readers to immerse themselves in particular aspects of the author's journey, fostering a richer understanding and connection. Moreover, by clustering related experiences or reflections, the author can highlight patterns, contrasts, or recurring motifs in their life. This can result in a layered, multifaceted portrayal where the sum of the themes offers a holistic yet detailed mosaic of a life lived. Thematic structuring, thus, beckons readers to not just skim the surface but to plunge into the depths of the writer's experiences and emotions.

Hybrid Approaches

Merging the linear clarity of chronology with the depth of thematic storytelling yields a narrative that offers readers the best of both worlds. Such an approach maintains a coherent timeline, helping readers easily follow the memoirist's journey through life's milestones. At the same time, thematic breaks intersperse the journey, allowing pauses for deeper introspection or exploration of pivotal moments. These thematic interludes can offer readers a chance to fully grasp the significance of events or periods in the author's life, illuminating their overarching narrative with vibrant, emotional spotlights. By blending both structures, memoirists craft a tapestry that is both sequentially clear and emotionally resonant, ensuring their story captivates from start to finish.

Choosing What's Right for You

Choosing What's Right for You: Finding the perfect structure for your memoir hinges on understanding both your story and your intended audience. Begin by reflecting on the essence of your narrative: Is it a journey of transformation that unfolds over time, or is it centered around pivotal themes or moments? Think about the emotions and insights you want to convey. Do you want your readers to walk step by step with you through the years, or do you want them to deeply explore specific phases of your life?

Once you've grasped the core of your tale, consider your readers. Some audiences might appreciate a linear progression, while others may relish a deep dive into thematic explorations. Remember, there's no one-size-fits-all approach. Your memoir is a deeply personal reflection of your experiences, and its structure should amplify its essence. Take the time to introspect, experiment, and most importantly, choose a structure that feels authentic to your unique story.

***

There's no one-size-fits-all in memoir writing. It's an art where the structure can make all the difference. Crafting a compelling memoir hinges not just on the events of your life but on how you choose to present them. Whether your narrative faithfully follows the hands of a clock or is pulled by the compelling tug of a heartstring, it's vital that it serves the story and its central message. Your story is unique, and its structure should echo its essence. Reflect on your memoir's journey today. Are you a chronologist, a themist, or a blend of both? Share your thoughts and plans in the comments below!